BEGIN NEW DATA CASE C BENCHMARK DCNEW-11 C Test of Type-59 S.M. model as inserted into SCE Navaho SSR simulation. C Data is close to DC-53 except for two critical changes. For second C subcase, only the switching times differ, whereas a very large time C step (1.0 msec) is illustrated. For the first subcase, imbalance has C been added, some branches have been removed, as have all 3 switches. C Modified under the direction of Prof. Juan Martinez in Barcelona, Spain. C At end of November, 1992, answer changes. Original data case is at end. C Answers change again 10 February 1999 following massive changes from C TEPCO (Tokyo Electric Power Company) in Japan. See April newsletter. C But changes are negligible physically. The printer plot is identical C most extrema numbers agree to 5th or 6th decimal digits or more. C Also, 2nd subcase is unaffected, just as DC-53 was unaffected. PRINTED NUMBER WIDTH, 11, 2, { 10 output columns/line, 2 blanks between columns .000100 .150 60. 60. { Note normal, small time step of 100 micros. 1 1 1 1 1 -1 5 5 20 20 100 100 51NAVH AMCC1 A 162.67 507.51 52NAVH BMCC1 B 6.51 162.97 53NAVH CMCC1 C MCC1 AMCC2 A 6885. { 1st of 3 is not equal to 2nd MCC1 BMCC2 B 8285. { Middle branch has value of DC-53 MCC1 CMCC2 C 9685. { 3rd of 3 is not equal to 2nd MCC2 AEQV A 19.52 MCC2 BEQV B 19.52 MCC2 CEQV C 19.52 TRANSFORMER TRAN A 9999 1NAVL ANAVL C .1 26. 2NAVH A 31.23 311.09 TRANSFORMER TRAN A TRAN B 1NAVL BNAVL A 2NAVH B TRANSFORMER TRAN A TRAN C 1NAVL CNAVL B 2NAVH C NAVL A 2500. 1.13 NAVL B 2500. 1.13 NAVL C 2500. 1.13 BLANK card ending branch cards C The switching of DC-53 is absent here; no such disturbance. BLANK card ending switch cards (nonexistent in this case) 14EQV A 389997. 60. -93.81293 -1. 14EQV B 389997. 60. -213.81293 -1. 14EQV C 389997. 60. 26.18707 -1. 59NAVL A 22680.58 60. -54.0211 NAVL B 22979.09 -173.4837 { Note imbalance of phase "b" NAVL C 23016.47 65.6058 { Note imbalance of phase "c" 1 1 2 1. 1. 892.4 26. -1800. 1971. 3050. { Q-axis saturation card } -1. 1.699938 1.66 1.66 1.79 1.66 1.665788 1.68448 1.58 1.58 1.71 1.58 1.82859 .13 .001048657.003712619.005256733.01838716 1 1. .8626875 BLANK card ending rotor mass cards 11 21 31 51 BLANK card that ends all Type-59 S.M. output requests FINISH BLANK card ending all source cards (including the U.M.) C Total network loss P-loss by summing injections = 1.163302277902E+07 C Last gen: EQV C 349966.92087687 389997. -971.2639768061 994.56516956163 C Last gen: 172106.98504408 26.1870700 214.02374602844 167.5731328 C negative sequence current. CMNEG, CANEG = 1.7691466407E+03 -2.4102642 C zero sequence current. CMZER, CAZER = 2.6519080001E-10 3.1004260 C Phase "a" injection Phase "b" injection C Magnitude Degrees Magnitude Degrees C Actual: 2.3843232E+04 -106.1941936 2.0780921E+04 134.0864766 C Pos. seq.: 2.2360894E+04 -103.7977668 2.2360894E+04 136.2022332 C Id, Iq, Io : -2.53616898057E+04 7.45565606771E+03 -4.58934787522E-10 C Field current of the generator: 4.9045746694E+03 4.9015187243E+03 C Electromechanical torque: 1.1286120653E+00 1.3137425906E+00 C Critical level of total air-gap MMF: 1.64767809698E+03 1.56827192364E+03 NAVH ANAVH BNAVH C C Step Time NAVH A NAVH B NAVH C MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 C ID IQ I0 C C MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 C IA IB IC EFD MFORCE MANG C 0 0.0 5599.6834 -385524.4 377160.9 -25361.69 7455.6561 -.4589E-9 C -6649.729 -14458.19 21107.915 -513.7626 2779.1613 .28315792 C 1 .1E-3 26730.203 -393133.6 363540.77 -25187.57 7475.4887 .25147E-8 C -5775.752 -15005.47 20781.226 -513.7626 2779.3697 .28320007 C 2 .2E-3 38231.503 -399254.6 358065.86 -25015.67 7506.4801 -.3989E-8 C -4893.915 -15531.11 20425.027 -513.7626 2779.6132 .28328413 BLANK card ending output requests (here, just node voltages) C 1500 .15 8215.5099 -385535.2 374535.31 -25151.67 7386.4018 -.662E-12 C -6559.891 -14365.26 20925.15 -513.7626 2779.4552 .28226463 C Variable max: 435639.24 432010.75 447141.66 -22925.62 11916.607 .68779E-8 C 24027.489 20616.106 22620.101 -513.7626 2794.7473 .29938993 C Times of max: .0208 .0763 .0318 .0268 .0373 .9E-3 C .0883 .0938 .049 0.0 .037 .0374 C Variable min: -435608.2 -433039.4 -447067.2 -28120.71 7280.2589 -.6854E-8 C -24045.91 -20648.92 -22645.71 -513.7626 2778.2618 .28204632 C Times of min: .0292 .0012 .0235 .0977 .0581 .8E-3 C .0966 .1355 .0407 0.0 .016 .1082 PRINTER PLOT 194 5. 50. MACH 1TQ GEN { Axis limits: (0.000, 1.514) BLANK card ending all plot cards BEGIN NEW DATA CASE C 2nd of two subcases showing Type-59 S.M. simulation. Here we balance C the electric network (see MCC1 A to MCC2 A and following 2 R-L-C C branches --- all equal), and run with 10 times the time-step size. C --- Modified with Guido's and Juan Martinez's approval during Oct., 1990. C --- Answers have changed. The original data case is unexecuted at end. PRINTED NUMBER WIDTH, 13, 2, { Request maximum precision (for 8 output columns) .001 .150 60. 60. { Note abnormally large time-step size 1 1 1 1 1 -1 5 5 20 20 51NAVH AMCC1 A 162.67 507.51 52NAVH BMCC1 B 6.51 162.97 53NAVH CMCC1 C MCC1 AMCC2 A 8285. { Unlike 1st subcase, here balance MCC1 BMCC2 B 8285. { Unlike 1st subcase, here balance MCC1 CMCC2 C 8285. { Unlike 1st subcase, here balance MCC2 AEQV A 19.52 MCC2 BEQV B 19.52 MCC2 CEQV C 19.52 TRANSFORMER TRAN A 9999 1NAVL ANAVL C .1 26. 2NAVH A 31.23 311.09 TRANSFORMER TRAN A TRAN B 1NAVL BNAVL A 2NAVH B TRANSFORMER TRAN A TRAN C 1NAVL CNAVL B 2NAVH C NAVL A 2500. 1.13 NAVL B 2500. 1.13 NAVL C 2500. 1.13 SWT AMCC2 A 4830. SWT BMCC2 B 4830. SWT CMCC2 C 4830. MCC2 ASWT A 13.01 MCC2 BSWT B 13.01 MCC2 CSWT C 13.01 BLANK card ending branch cards SWT A 0. .075 { DC-53 uses T-clo, T-open: .01661667 .09161667 SWT B 0. .075 { DC-53 uses T-clo, T-open: .01661667 .09161667 SWT C 0. .075 { DC-53 uses T-clo, T-open: .01661667 .09161667 BLANK card ending switch cards 14EQV A 389997. 60. -93.81293 -1. 14EQV B 389997. 60. -213.81293 -1. 14EQV C 389997. 60. 26.18707 -1. 59NAVL A 21229. 60. -44.896562 NAVL B NAVL C C Following TOLERANCES card is new (added 13 October 1990). C Note: After Prof. Juan Martinez's changes of October, 1989, the speed C iteration of the Type-59 S.M. has been slowed for some reason. C The old data used the default limit of 10 iterations, which led C to an error stop on the first time-step. We increase the limit C to 20 one year later, and all is well. WSM and JM, 13 October 90 TOLERANCES 20 PARAMETER FITTING 2. { +1800 below ignores saturation 6 5 6 2 1. 1. 892.4 26. 1800. BLANK card for Q-axis saturation? .13 1.79 1.71 .169 .228 .13504 .20029 4.3 .85 .032 .05 .13 1 .3 .027691 33.68813 2 .26 .046379 60.9591 3 .22 .255958 90.81823 4 .22 .263573 123.6634 5 .258887 4.925036 6 .0101995 BLANK card ending rotor mass cards 2 5 6 8 2 51 11 31 41 BLANK card that ends all Type-59 S.M. output requests FINISH BLANK card ending all source cards (including the U.M.) C Total network loss P-loss by summing injections = 1.775782562050E+07 C Last gen: EQV C 349966.92087687 389997. -1273.1121012 1348.5241961806 C Last gen: 172106.98504408 26.1870700 -444.6381511542 -160.7480946 C Id, Iq, Io : -3.15542117823E+04 1.32614561915E+04 2.52046565230E-11 C Field current of the generator: 4.3132669924E+03 4.3132669924E+03 C Electromechanical torque: 2.1243643866E+00 2.1243643866E+00 C Exciter electromechanical torque: 6.9376969460E-03 6.9376969460E-03 C Critical level of total air-gap MMF: 1.64767815421E+03 1.54285260456E+03 NAVH ANAVH BNAVH C C Step Time NAVH A NAVH B NAVH C MACH 1 MACH 1 C ID IQ C C MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 C IG IKQ IA IB IC C C MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 C TQ GEN TQ EXC ANG 2 ANG 5 ANG 6 C C MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 C VEL 4 VEL 5 VEL 6 TOR 1 TOR 2 C *** Switch "SWT A" to " " closed after 0.00000000E+00 sec. C *** Switch "SWT B" to " " closed after 0.00000000E+00 sec. C *** Switch "SWT C" to " " closed after 0.00000000E+00 sec. C 0 0.0 54291.79404 -385072.51 330780.7161 -31554.2118 13261.45619 C -.1483E-11 -.77929E-11 9214.69265 -27456.5111 18241.81844 C 2.124364387 .0069376969 88.7845725 86.45613646 86.39662907 C 0.0 .568434E-13 0.0 .6393906251 1.193529167 C 1 .001 174073.2365 -337932.389 163859.1521 -35450.7946 14276.51122 C -19.0383823 -65.3413592 20939.5491 -30711.2398 9771.69074 C 2.353853632 .0069876924 88.7845725 86.45583635 86.39662625 C -.39289E-4 -.01047592 -.984784E-4 .6393906251 1.193529171 BLANK card ending output requests (here, just node voltages) C 150 .15 104120.6498 -549880.101 370127.7961 -10378.3288 61259.50668 C -918.769883 -3222.21883 50081.07325 -27679.4258 -22401.6474 C 4.077244752 .0059772423 97.53252996 96.26891526 90.87958692 C 3.298889083 4.442742009 18.01072049 .3456291178 .4410601898 C Variable max: 584560.4323 523526.0746 482640.6539 24211.12592 73069.06183 C 1218.279553 3694.25919 70874.41849 58367.25927 74193.34934 C 6.953584119 .0099150625 100.2577288 96.26891526 99.81642058 C 4.363352162 4.570081111 18.01072049 1.793972008 3.631195484 C Times of max: .104 .143 .147 .097 .11 C .028 .027 .12 .028 .113 C .111 .075 .135 .15 .116 C .144 .095 .15 .083 .133 C Variable min: -515451.327 -592812.443 -535266.411 -88064.2423 -46392.7197 C -1106.26611 -4026.24392 -73843.3003 -66442.5528 -70813.3153 C -1.64765566 .0059717165 87.73359188 85.82030263 85.38065158 C -1.43086845 -1.52953914 -15.1785599 -.657183376 -1.30826843 C Times of min: .145 0.1 .106 .015 .027 C .11 .11 .11 .019 .025 C .086 .149 .05 .023 .034 C .123 .12 .129 .106 .106 PRINTER PLOT 194 5. 50. MACH 1ID { Axis limits: (-8.806, 0.000) CALCOMP PLOT 19415. 150. MACH 1TQ GEN BLANK card ending all plot cards BEGIN NEW DATA CASE BLANK BEGIN NEW DATA CASE C BENCHMARK DCNEW-11 C Test of Type-59 S.M. model as inserted into SCE Navaho SSR simulation. C Data is close to DC-53 except for two critical changes. For second C subcase, only the switching times differ, whereas a very large time C step (1.0 msec) is illustrated. For the first subcase, imbalance has C been added, some branches have been removed, as have all 3 switches. C This is old data case, as it existed prior to December, 1992 changes. C Only the 1st of 2 subcases, having saturation, was affected. PRINTED NUMBER WIDTH, 11, 2, { 10 output columns/line, 2 blanks between columns .000100 .150 60. 60. { Note normal, small time step of 100 micros. 1 1 1 1 1 -1 5 5 20 20 100 100 51NAVH AMCC1 A 162.67 507.51 52NAVH BMCC1 B 6.51 162.97 53NAVH CMCC1 C MCC1 AMCC2 A 6885. { 1st of 3 is not equal to 2nd MCC1 BMCC2 B 8285. { Middle branch has value of DC-53 MCC1 CMCC2 C 9685. { 3rd of 3 is not equal to 2nd MCC2 AEQV A 19.52 MCC2 BEQV B 19.52 MCC2 CEQV C 19.52 TRANSFORMER TRAN A 9999 1NAVL ANAVL C .1 26. 2NAVH A 31.23 311.09 TRANSFORMER TRAN A TRAN B 1NAVL BNAVL A 2NAVH B TRANSFORMER TRAN A TRAN C 1NAVL CNAVL B 2NAVH C NAVL A 2500. 1.13 NAVL B 2500. 1.13 NAVL C 2500. 1.13 BLANK card ending branch cards C The switching of DC-53 is absent here; no such disturbance. BLANK card ending switch cards (nonexistent in this case) 14EQV A 389997. 60. -93.81293 -1. 14EQV B 389997. 60. -213.81293 -1. 14EQV C 389997. 60. 26.18707 -1. 59NAVL A 22680.58 60. -54.0211 NAVL B 22979.09 -173.4837 { Note imbalance of phase "b" NAVL C 23016.47 65.6058 { Note imbalance of phase "c" 1 1 2 1. 1. 892.4 26. -1800. 1971. 3050. { Q-axis saturation card } -1. 1.699938 1.66 1.66 1.79 1.66 1.665788 1.68448 1.58 1.58 1.71 1.58 1.82859 .13 .001048657.003712619.005256733.01838716 1 1. .8626875 BLANK card ending rotor mass cards 11 21 31 51 BLANK card that ends all Type-59 S.M. output requests FINISH BLANK card ending all source cards (including the U.M.) C Total network loss P-loss by summing injections = 1.163302277902E+07 C Last gen: EQV C 349966.92087687 389997. -971.2639768061 994.56516956163 C Last gen: 172106.98504408 26.1870700 214.02374602844 167.5731328 C negative sequence current. CMNEG, CANEG = 1.7691466407E+03 -2.4102642 C zero sequence current. CMZER, CAZER = 2.7353740917E-10 -3.0706010 C Phase "a" injection Phase "b" injection C Magnitude Degrees Magnitude Degrees C Actual: 2.3843232E+04 -106.1941936 2.0780921E+04 134.0864766 C Pos. seq.: 2.2360894E+04 -103.7977668 2.2360894E+04 136.2022332 C Id, Iq, Io : -2.53612689520E+04 7.45708752411E+03 -4.72587309806E-10 C Field current of the generator: 5.5452995580E+03 5.5422562163E+03 C Electromechanical torque: 1.1130233521E+00 1.3137425906E+00 C Critical level of total air-gap MMF: 1.64767815421E+03 1.54285260456E+03 NAVH ANAVH BNAVH C C Step Time NAVH A NAVH B NAVH C MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 C ID IQ I0 C C MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 MACH 1 C IA IB IC EFD MFORCE MANG C 0 0.0 5599.6834 -385524.4 377160.9 -25361.27 7457.0875 -.4505E-9 C -6649.729 -14458.19 21107.915 -580.9228 3395.4664 .22584782 C 1 .1E-3 13085.416 -390180.1 374232. -25223.92 7476.9523 .25149E-8 C -5796.276 -15015.04 20811.319 -580.9228 3395.6875 .2259019 C 2 .2E-3 37828.479 -398608.8 357822.77 -25088.33 7504.2792 -.3991E-8 C -4936.097 -15549.08 20485.175 -580.9228 3395.9341 .22598696 BLANK card ending output requests (here, just node voltages) C 1500 .15 6837.3696 -387443.2 377929.02 -25561.24 8765.6491 -.272E-11 C -5791.244 -15542.29 21333.536 -580.9228 3400.4457 .22974172 C Variable max: 437711.89 436396.74 452297.2 -23535.78 11308.112 .6877E-8 C 23270.336 21727.34 22760.711 -580.9228 3410.6932 .24092559 C Times of max: .0208 .0096 .0318 .0685 .0375 .9E-3 C .0382 .1271 .0825 0.0 .0371 .0376 C Variable min: -437366.3 -434952.8 -452173.8 -27271.05 7457.0875 -.6855E-8 C -23480. -21940.25 -22982.56 -580.9228 3395.4664 .22584782 C Times of min: .0292 .018 .0068 .0398 0.0 .001 C .0299 .0854 .0408 0.0 0.0 0.0 PRINTER PLOT 194 5. 50. MACH 1TQ GEN { Axis limits: (0.000, 1.474) BLANK card ending all plot cards